Social Media Hijacks Teen Identity Formation
Why teenagers are adopting diagnostic labels and how it affects their mental health
The central developmental task of adolescence is identity formation. Teenagers try out different identities to figure out who they are, using labels as a means to understand themselves and to fit into various social groups and communities. This process has always been challenging, but it has become uniquely difficult with the rise of social media.
Social media platforms, driven by algorithms that promote engaging–and often inflammatory–content, have made discourse in online communities particularly heated and lacking in nuance. Teenagers, in their quest for identity and acceptance, are especially vulnerable to online narratives: they naturally exhibit black-and-white thinking and a strong desire to fit in. Social media exacerbates these tendencies by providing simplified, binary narratives and communities that validate certain labels.
These trends extend to online communities of individuals with neurodevelopmental disorders (e.g. ADHD, autism) and psychopathology (e.g. anxiety, depression). There, teenagers may readily adopt diagnostic labels to find acceptance, attention, and validation. They are motivated to use the language of pathology to describe or excuse their struggles, even when these struggles are a normal part of development.
This tendency is detrimental to teenagers' mental health. By adopting diagnostic labels for their struggles, they develop a diminished understanding of personal growth and resilience. They begin to see their challenges as permanent conditions rather than opportunities for development and learning.
To support teenagers, it is crucial to encourage critical thinking and provide nuanced perspectives that go beyond simplistic, pathological explanations. By fostering environments that value authenticity and resilience, we can help young people develop a healthier understanding of themselves and their potential for growth.
***
Not Broadway, but wow!