Perhaps you’ve seen the recent New York Magazine article titled “Pediatricians Are Not Psychiatrists.” It argues that primary care providers are ill-equipped to fill the gap between the mental health care kids need and what their families can actually access. As I read it, I kept thinking there should be a companion piece about how educators are ill-equipped to fill that gap, too. So here it is!
Let’s start with an example. Elizabeth was worried that her daughter Danielle’s anxiety was causing her to do poorly on tests. She came to my office for an evaluation, hoping I could recommend testing accommodations and mental health support from the school counselor. Truthfully, once I met Danielle, it became clear that the tests were the least of her worries. Danielle was really struggling. She was routinely having panic attacks in school and missing long stretches of instruction while she calmed down with the school nurse. Elizabeth was right that her daughter needed help, but she was looking to the wrong institution to provide it. I told her the school could offer accommodations and counseling support as a stopgap, but she needed to seek formal treatment for Danielle’s anxiety in an outpatient clinical setting.
Elizabeth was frustrated. She was resistant to the idea of clinical treatment. She said she couldn’t possibly add one more thing to Danielle’s already overloaded plate, and therapy was far too time-consuming, inconvenient, and expensive. She also believed academic accommodations would be more effective than treatment at solving the immediate problem, which, in her view, was Danielle’s low test scores. School was causing Danielle’s anxiety, so school should reduce it.
On one hand, I can empathize with parents like Elizabeth. Kids spend most of their waking hours in school. It’s where they encounter most of their problems, and it’s where parents hope those problems can be solved.
On the other hand, I can also empathize with schools when they feel they’re being tasked with a kind of psychological care that’s outside their scope. The school is responsible for educating the child, but it usually isn’t equipped to provide psychiatric treatment.
That last point highlights a really important distinction we all need to appreciate: Schools should support children’s mental health, but supporting mental health is not the same as treating mental illness. Schools have substantial responsibilities in the former, but their responsibilities and abilities are limited in the latter. That’s why the supportive services schools offer are (reasonably and appropriately) very different from actual clinical treatment.
To be clear, schools do have an important role in supporting children’s psychological well-being. Schools are obligated to provide environments in which kids feel safe, connected, and challenged. Educators are expected to notice changes in social, emotional, and behavioral functioning, and to communicate concerns to families.
Schools must also accommodate students with disabilities, including those related to social, emotional, and behavioral needs. Mental health disorders may at times be disabling, meaning they prevent equal access to education, and disabled students are entitled to reasonable accommodations and services so they learn on par with nondisabled peers.
Despite these responsibilities, schools can’t be venues for psychological treatment because educators are not clinicians. Teachers don’t have the same competencies as mental health professionals, and it’s irresponsible to put teachers in that role without the expertise, time, or institutional support that clinical care requires.
Many schools offer counseling, but even that isn’t the same as treatment. School counselors, psychologists, and social workers serve important functions, like supporting adjustment, coping, problem-solving, and academic achievement. Those functions are very different from providing evidence-based treatment for psychopathology. Sure, some school psychologists, counselors, and social workers have substantial clinical training and are licensed to provide psychotherapy outside of schools, but genuine psychiatric treatment is a clinical service, and it should be provided in clinical settings.
As I’ve written many times before, we’ve pushed psychiatric treatment into schools because mental health care is difficult to access. Therapy is a luxury good available only to affluent families. Unless people pay high out-of-pocket costs, they face long waitlists and provider shortages, and it’s all but impossible to find a clinician who offers affordable care in a place and at a time that works for them. When the healthcare system fails to meet children’s needs, it’s no surprise that parents turn to schools as the default source of support. But instead of expecting the education system to compensate for failures in healthcare, parents must demand the healthcare system fix itself.
In the short-term, though, this may seem pretty bleak. Kids can’t access adequate mental health support, and they can’t rely on their most familiar and trusted institutions to fill the gap. If we can’t depend on pediatricians or on schools, where should we go? The solution, as I have been saying (screaming!) over and over, is mental health primary care. Sorry if I sound like a broken record, but I think this point is worth repeating!
We’ve long established routine preventive medical care, and now it’s time to establish routine preventive psychological care. Just as children visit pediatricians for annual well visits, they should attend annual mental health well visits, too, led by appropriately trained mental health professionals. Most difficulties can be resolved with low-intensity interventions, but if problems seem more severe, or if those initial interventions don’t work, a mental health primary care provider can recommend formal assessment or treatment with a specialist. Annual visits could potentially normalize psychological care, prevent problems from escalating, and reduce the pressure to get a diagnosis simply to access help. Importantly, families would no longer need to depend on pediatricians or schools as their default sources of mental health services.
We need to take our kids’ psychological well-being as seriously as their medical and educational well-being, and we need to demand a mental healthcare system that does the same.



I wish children visited pediatricians for annual well visits… wait lists are so long and the expense makes them unreachable for many. Something drastic needs to change.
Um....NO! There are a few very good reasons that parents DON'T want their children seen by a counselor or psychologist. The quality in that profession is down the tubes and all it does now is persist with constant navel gazing, emphasis on "perceived" trauma and gender issues. Gone are the good old days of Jungian care. The system of school needs to change to accommodate the children! The endless standardized testing and teaching to those tests should be the #1 issue to tackle to help children deal with the anxiety they are having.