I met Lucy when she was seven years old. At the start of second grade, her reading skills were, to put it lightly, abysmal. Her parents told me that, at curriculum night, Lucy’s teachers said the kids should begin reading chapter books. Lucy, meanwhile, was still struggling to get through early reader picture books that included anything more complicated than simple CVC words like cat and sun.
Lucy’s spelling was just as bad. Her writing was incomprehensible; the words were hardly phonological approximations of correct spellings, and there was no rhyme or reason to the letters she was using. Most of the time, she seemed to be guessing.
Lucy, for her part, was a shy, nervous child. She said she hated school. It was boring, she was stupid, and she couldn’t do what the other kids were able to do.
Unsurprisingly, when we conducted a neuropsychological evaluation, Lucy’s academic skills measured well below average. Her intellectual abilities were totally solid, though, and when I observed her in the classroom, it was clear she was receiving high-quality instruction, so I felt confident diagnosing her with a Specific Learning Disorder in Reading.
I explained to Lucy’s parents that she struggled with manipulating the sounds of language and linking those sounds to letter symbols, so dyslexia was an appropriate term to describe her disorder. Her parents were understandably upset; the word dyslexia seemed to imply that life would be extremely hard for their child. I tried to reassure them that the disorder was actually highly treatable, and that with the right interventions, Lucy would absolutely learn how to read.
I gave them a referral for a good Orton-Gillingham tutor named Dana, recommended some school supports and accommodations, and told them to bring Lucy back for a reassessment in three years unless something meaningful changed before then.
Sure enough, I didn’t hear from them again until Lucy was ten, when her parents dutifully brought her back for a reevaluation. Now a fifth grader, Lucy came into my office looking much more confident in her skills. She had developed a stronger self-concept, especially as a learner.
Lucy’s parents also reported that she had come a very long way. Sure, she still wasn’t among the top students in her class. She was resistant to doing her homework and never seemed to want to read for fun. But she could keep her head afloat, and her grades were solid.
Her parents attributed the improvement to effective interventions, and specifically to Dana, who they said was life-changing. About a year earlier, Dana had stopped the formal reading instruction she’d been doing, but she and Lucy had built such a nice relationship that Lucy wasn’t willing to let her go, so they shifted to informal homework help. Her parents called it glorified babysitting, but they were glad to keep Dana on the payroll so long as Lucy was happy and learning.
On formal testing, Lucy’s academic skills were just as her parents described: average. Her reading and writing skills measured around the 37th percentile. Not incredible, but definitely okay. Near the bottom of the average range, but still well within normal limits.
In my diagnostic formulation, I told Lucy’s parents that, since her reading skills were now at grade level, she no longer met criteria for a learning disorder. I removed the label from my evaluation and from her superbills. Her parents were surprised. They thought dyslexia was a forever thing.
I directed their attention to the diagnostic criteria in the DSM, which hinge on academic skills that are below average for grade level. Lucy’s skills weren’t below average anymore, so the diagnosis no longer fit.
It’s a common misconception that diagnostic labels are permanent descriptors. In reality, they describe how a person is functioning at a given moment in time. They are mere snapshots. Yes, neurodevelopmental disorders cause chronic impairment for many people, and no, those problems don’t disappear overnight. But people are always growing and developing and learning, and skills are responsive to intervention. So our diagnostic labels are appropriately fluid. Something that fits at one point in time may not fit at another.
This is exactly how we want it to be. A major purpose of diagnosis is to link a person to interventions, and, ideally, we want those interventions to work so well that the diagnostic label stops being relevant.
Lucy was a perfect example of this process in action. Reading may always be hard for her. It will probably always be a relatively slow, effortful process, and it’s conceivable she may never enjoy it. At the same time, the interventions taught her to read. She can do it. Her academic performance is at the expected level. She’s no longer disordered.
Let’s all keep this in mind when we talk about diagnoses. The last thing I want is for labels to be growth-limiting, and for people to think a label means there’s a ceiling on what they can accomplish. On the contrary, a label should provide a roadmap for meaningful support, intervention, and growth.
T-minus one week until AYF!
New Yorkers, I’d love to see you at the book launch!



Thank you for writing about this issue with such parsimony, objectivity, and calm clarity. I have been trying to write similar things because my father, son, and I are like Lucy and I’m the founder of a small Montessori school. I care deeply about how we educate children in our time and place.
My father wasn’t lucky enough to have a Dana. I didn’t find my first one until I was 10 (Reading Recovery *didn’t* work for me like Hooked on Phonics promised it would have in the TV ads of the 90s). We found my son’s Danas at 6, a Wilson-based literacy coach (he still works with once a week) and a speech therapist. My son was just three quarters way through his kindergarten year in a Montessori program during COVID. He’d both already and only been seriously frustrated by difficulties with phonological processing for about a year. He wasn’t learning to read and write like his friends despite age-appropriate, phonics-based instruction. He was also having trouble articulating his increasingly complex thoughts to strangers, teachers, acquaintances, and extended family through a fairly severe speech articulation delay. (He wasn’t developing rhoticity, perhaps, in part, because three of his grandparents were born into very non-rhotic dialects of English in England and New England and the other one speaks with a thick French accent?)
He’s in 4th grade now and has just transferred to his large urban public district’s gifted academy after three great years in his neighborhood elementary school. His permanent record is absurdly stamped with both “moderate dyslexia” on his 504 plan and “identified gifted in reading” on his standardized test reports which, in part, qualified him for the academy. His spelling and handwriting still look terrible compared to similarly tracked peers but they are both technically on grade level. He’s actually enjoyed reading for a couple of years now and the Matthew effect has done its work there: he’s reading well above grade level powered by excellent vocab and background knowledge.
All and all, I wholeheartedly support your functional, pragmatic approach to the diagnosis of learning disabilities. There is a piece of me that will always feel dyslexic. I’ll always marvel at the abilities some possess to write and read and carry on conversation all at once. I’ll never read with the speed and ease of the other moms with their beach reads tucked into their bags as they enter the public pool. But I’ve read hundreds of great novels since *1984* opened the door to them for me at 12. And I just wrote this with my thumbs on my phone in a few happy minutes. It would be absurd for me to claim an identity as a disabled person. I have used my superior literacy to secure both economic and social status for myself and my family. I will use it now to secure more “Dana”, more access to better support, for the next generation.
There needs to be the option to revisit and remove these labels when they cease to fit for whatever reason. I don’t think that every child receiving these types of labels requires them to be life-long as specially as we expand the boundaries without developing concrete understanding of their cause and lack objective neurobiological markers/tests to confirm such assumptions at the individual scale.